VERNON GIVERNY ... PASSIONATELY
VERNON AND GiVERNY WELCOME YOU
Home page
Shops, services & useful addresses
DISCOVER VERNON AND GIVERNY
What to see and to visit
Almost 20 pages here for
ANOTHER WAY OF LOOKING AT...
... Vernon
... Giverny
The making of Claude Monet's garden
Giverny, where crossbreeding takes place
Monet, the Seine and Normandy
List of plants and flowers
Calendar of flowering times
Giverny, an American colony
Giverny in Uncle Sam's country : Old Lyme and Cos Cob
Giverny in the land of the Rising Sun : Kitagawa
OTHER INFORMATION
Contact our site and the Tourist Office
Discover the surroundings & Normandy (links)
VIRTUAL VISIT OF THE COLLEGIATE CHURCH
Created May 2005

 



 

 

Giverny: an American colony


Former Hotel Baudy [1]


The discovery of Giverny by artists (Americans for the majority) blends history and legend. If we believe what people say in Vernon and Giverny, an American painter, Willard Leroy Metcalf, would have discovered Giverny in 1886 by chance on his own, without even knowing that Monet was living there; he would have been the first guest of what was to become the celebrated Hotel Baudy and a whole group of painters would have settled there in the following weeks and months.

However, it seems that the reason why Metcalf came to Giverny was not painting but picking and collecting egg shells: instead of talking about painting with Claude Monet, he is likely to have discussed botany and ornithology with the master's children.

[2]
But the most important element to question the explanation usually given in Giverny is the very date: 1886, because Metcalf was here as early as 1885. The Historical Museum in Old Lyme (Connecticut, USA) preserves a fine collection of egg shells that Metcalf gathered all along in life, and particularly while he was in Giverny - among which is a blackbird egg which he dated May 1885! Did he come to Giverny for painting or for ornithology? Both probably ( we know for instance that, later, he used to go for long walks looking for birds and plants with Monet's children) but in 1885.

Well, when did the first American painters arrive in Giverny ? We know that John Singer Sargent was staying there in 1885 - one year before Metcalf's supposed "discovery" of the village (according to what is said locally) - and had been working with Monet (Some historians of art believe that Sargent had met Monet as early as 1876)

What is a fact is Sargent's painting "Claude Monet Painting at the Edge of a Wood" (Tate Gallery, London) which shows the Master working on a canvas that he signed in 1885 (A haystack, now in a Boston museum). There is also a letter by Monet, dated September 20, 1885, in which he relates Sargent's recent visit.

[3] Claude Monet Painting at the Edge of a Wood - John Sargent -
Tate Gallery, Londres.


In addition, one can also imagine that Theodore Robinson went to Giverny the same year (or at least that he knew of the presence of Monet there) because he was introduced to Monet this very year by Deconchy, a painter who lived in Gasny (a village only four kilometres away from Giverny.)

Other sources tell a different story : the English painter Dawson Dawson-Watson recalls that Leslie Breck would have described him this first visit to Giverny as follows : "In the spring of '87 [he and] Willard Metcalf, Theodore Robinson, Blair-Bruce, Theo Wendel, and a chap named Taylor whose Christian name I cannot recall [it was Henry Fitch Taylor], were talking over some place to go to for the summer. All of the usual places, Pont Aven, Etretat, Ecoigu, and Grèz, were rejected because they were interested in finding a new location for painting. After consulting the destination board at the Gare St. Lazare, they agreed that Pont de l'Arche was appealing, so they decided to visit the town and see if it was as picturesque as its name. The train to Pont de l'Arche followed the Seine into Normandy and required a change at Vernon. As they approached Vernon, Metcalf pointed out a little village of white houses and a Norman church at the base of the hill on the opposite bank of the river and commented on its loveliness. At Vernon they were told the village was Giverny. Once aboard the new train they were treated to a second view of Giverny when they crossed the Seine and were doubling back. The painters agreed unanimously that if Pont de l'Arche was not to their liking they would return to Giverny the following morning, which was exactly what they did."

Mr D. Scott Atkinson, former curator of the Terra Foundation, and as such, an expert about impressionist painters in Giverny, writes: "This account is suspect for it is known that both Metcalf and Wendel had been in the village the preceding year. This anecdote provides a chronicle of the founding of the colony by a group, as opposed to visits to Giverny by individual artists."

But it is possible to question the anecdote once and for all. First it has now been established that Metcalf and other artists were in Giverny as early as 1885. Second, read again the sentence that Breck is supposed to have said : "Once aboard the new train they were treated to a second view of Giverny when they crossed the Seine and were doubling back." This sentence describes a route which travellers to Pont de l'Arche could not possibly have taken: the line described here is the Vernon - Gisors line, that crossed the river Seine, then "doubled back" yes, but on the right bank this time and ran through Giverny to go as far as Gisors, from which station it was impossible to travel to Pont de l'Arche. In order to get there, passengers had to take the Vernon - Pacy line (and from there the line along the Eure valley) which did not cross the Seine and ran too far away from Giverny for anyone to have a look at the village. To sum it up, the story told locally of Metcalf arriving in Giverny by chance, but alone, may be plausible but it was clearly in 1885, not 1886 and even less in 1887.

The Seine in Vernon. In the background, one can just make out the railway bridge which the artists claim to have crossed.[4]

It hardly matters to know who arrived first and how. The fact is that , by 1887, lots of painters were at work in Giverny. They were attracted by the homely atmosphere, the shimmering light of the Seine valley and ' the Normandy sky with its clouds and rain every half-hour" as J. Carroll Beckwith (active in Giverny in 1891) would say.

William Blair Bruce, a Canadian, who had worked mainly in Barbizon and Grez-sur-Loing, was enthusiastic about the surroundings. In a letter to his mother dated June 1887, he wrote about "the new settlement which we have formed here in this most beautiful part of France, the river Seine flowing by almost at our door" and he added that Giverny was "far ahead of Barbizon in every respect."

IIt is well know that Giverny, when Monet settled there, was an farming village with a population of about 300, most of them farmers and farm labourers. This agrarian aspect is illustrated by Bruce's 'Rain in Giverny', which shows a woman carrying a sheaf of hay. She is walking downhill to the village and in the distance, we can see the red-tiled houses of the village and farther away the right bank of the Seine with its wooded hills.

William Blair Bruce, Rain in Giverny, 1887
Spanierman Gallery LLC [5]

We know that the inhabitants of Giverny were totally unprepared (both commercially and socially) for the coming of young artists, most of them being foreigners, who flocked in as soon as word of Monet's presence had spread among them. The village, typically agricultural at the time, had only a few cafés, a grocery and nothing that could make a cultural and artistic centre of attention. But this may be the reason why Monet had chosen it for it enabled him to live as a country gentleman more interested in his garden than in society life.

However some villagers managed to take advantage of the lack of facilities by creating lucrative businesses. The Baudy hotel is certainly the best example since the owners of the modest drinking place turned it into an international leisure resort. According to Dawson-Watson's account, it seems that it is Breck who talked the Baudys into building six rooms in the courtyard as well as a studio for Metcalf. And Dawson-Watson adds "Then Breck went to Paris and I happened to be the first chap he met. That was in April of '87. I went there [hotel Baudy] for two weeks as a try and stayed there five years". Robinson was the first guest of the hotel, inaugurated in January 1888.


Hotel Baudy around 1900 [6]



The dining room in 1900 [7]


Hotel Baudy in 1925 [8]

The Baudys would welcome all the artists who came and their guest book, in which they had to note down the name of every guest, looks like a true international "Who's Who" of art. The place was not only a hotel, but the main meeting place for social and artistic life and it is likely that, without Lucien and Angelina Baudy's commercial but also social sense, Giverny would probably never have become an artist colony. The Baudys built a studio in the garden and other sky-lit studio spaces under the roofs - sometimes to answer a single artist's request, for instance for Cézanne's fairly long stay in Giverny in 1894 - and the couple became famous high-end art suppliers. (Pissarro wrote to a friend : "Go to Baudy hotel, you will find there everything you need for painting;" Two tennis courts - for a game that was practically unknown of in France - were added on a plot of land across the road, facing the hotel.


The studio built for Metcalf


Studio [9] and [10]
Below: one of the tennis courts [12]


Rose garden of Hotel Baudy[11]

A society unknown to the villagers would go there to spend the summer and would sometimes stay longer or even decide to settle there for years.
This was what Mary and Frederick Mac Monnies did: they had come to Giverny as early as 1894 but in 1898 they settled in a former monastery, which their friends had nicknamed the 'MacMonastery', today 'Le Moutier', one of the most beautiful estates in Giverny. the garden, which Mary used to paint in all seasons, was said to rival Monet's.
Although Frederick did paint a lot when in Giverny, he was a sculptor first of all , one of the leading figurative sculptors of the American Renaissance. (Several works by the MacMonnies can be seen in Vernon museum.)

Another example was Stanton Young, a resident of Hotel Baudy, who later settled in an old mill in Giverny.
Another example still was Mary Colman Wheeler, who, in addition to being an acknowledged artist, also ran a select private school in Providence, Rhode Island (near Boston). She used to send her students to Giverny, where she had bought a farmhouse, for them to learn painting from some of the great impressionist painters. During the early 1900s, Richard Miller, another famous painter and a close friend of Carl Frieseke, conducted several of these summer painting classes. Miller remained in Giverny until 1914.


MacMonnies' workshop[13]


The garden of Le Moutier, by Mary MacMonnies, (Vernon Museum) [14]


Behind the railway line, the one that ran in the middle of Monet's gardens, one can see the former mill belonging to Stanton Young in 1910, when the photo was taken. [15]

The first wave of painters were professionals - students or mature artists - but, as time passed, novice painters, amateurs also arrived, often young women for whom spending a few weeks in an artist colony was more a social obligation or a pleasant summer entertainment than an artistic requirement.


Maison Rose, one of the places where painters used to stay [16]


Mr Jardin's café where regular customers used to come for an aperitif before their meals [17]

A lively social life - international but mainly Franco-American - had developed in Giverny. Baudy was the "American painters' hotel" where everyone would dance at night sipping their whisky - a drink that the Baudys were among the first to import in France. The bill that Cézanne paid at the bar is well known : "Mister Cézanne, two whiskies with Mister Monet".

These young people used to live a sometimes bohemian life that did not always show respect for more traditional moral standards. In addition to paintings showing women in perfectly 'respectable' attitudes and clothes, Carl Frieseke also painted suggestive nudes in the sunshine, which he would never have dared to do, had he been at home in Michigan, as he admitted in several letters. Le Moutier, MacMonnies' former monastery, had a reputation for being a place where the standards of behaviour were somewhat free ( it was "an almost libertine party zone" writes Derrick Cartwright)

In 1897 there were so many people in Giverny that Monet said: "When I first came to Giverny I was quite alone, the little village was unspoiled. Now, so many artists, students, flock here, I have often thought of moving away."
Of course, he did not leave Giverny but he estranged himself from the artist colony, inviting only a few close friends such as Sargent (Monet had some paintings of his in his own bedroom), Robinson or Lila Cabot Perry who organised the first Monet exhibition in the USA and sold the first Monet there. Breck, who had made a very significant inroad into the Monet family, was asked to 'clear out' when it appeared that he was courting Blanche Hoschedé and Monet complained that he was overrun by 'damned Americans'. Monet could not accept Blanche marrying this man and if her sister Suzanne married Theodore Butler- another painter- it was not before Monet had hesitated a long time before giving his consent. There is for instance a letter that he wrote to Alice: "I find this idea [the marriage with Butler] worrying. It is your duty, after what happened, to refuse your daughter to an American unless you happen to know him either by means of mutual acquaintances or if he is introduced to you, but not if he is a man met on the road." This wedding was painted by Robinson and the canvas is perhaps his masterpiece.


Monet's garden , by John Leslie Breck
Terra Foundation [18]


Theodore Butler [19]

Wedding March, by Theodore Robinson
Terra Foundation [20]

The 1914-18 war meant the waning of the colony : most of the artists left and very few came back once peace was signed and Monet's death in 1926 dealt the fatal blow. In the 1930's a few surrealist painters and writers (among whom was Aragon) helped the village retain some of its reputation as a place for artistic creation and then the village fell into oblivion. Monet's house where Blanche lived until her death in 1947, was to remain empty since Michel Monet, the master's last son, no longer lived there. There were piles of paintings lying about in the rooms, the gardens were overgrown with brambles and nettles.

These artists, once they had left Giverny, would return to their country, to the USA where they founded new colonies, in Shinnecock (New York State), in Monhegan Island (Maine), in Gloucester and Provincetown ( Massachusetts). We can also mention Cos Cob colony, one of the most important ones were Childe Hassam, John H. Twachtman and Theodore Robinson worked, and do not forget Old Lyme, dubbed an 'American Giverny' where Miss Florence Griswold's house had become a kind of replica of Giverny's Baudy hotel.


Florence Griswold's house in Lyme [20]

After years of neglect, the revival of Giverny came when the 'Académie des Beaux Arts' created the Claude Monet Foundation and undertook gigantic restoration work to bring the estate back to life. In the years that followed, Terra Foundation and private investors completed the revival of these historic places of such cultural importance.


Claude Monet's house [21]

 


Webography :


The Values of Cultural Exchange. '
Lecture given for the 'Association française d'études américaines' in Aix-en-Provence, on May 26, 2000 by Derrick R. Cartwright, former curator of the American Art Museum in Giverny.
http://etudes.americaines.free.fr/TRANSATLANTICA/1/cartwright.pdf

Theodore Robinson: Pioneer of American Impressionis.
The continuation of an essay was written in March 2000 for the catalogue of the Theodore Robinson exhibition held at Owen Gallery, New York in 2000 by by D. Scott Atkinson, former curator at the Terra Foundation, Chicago.
http://www.tfaoi.com/aa/2aa/2aa562.htm


French Connections: American Expatriate Artists in the Age of Impressionism.
Lecture given by Professor Charles Stuckey for the Royal Academy of Arts, London, on Thursday 13 November 2003
http://www.royalacademy.org.uk/?lid=1101

William Blair Bruce - Rain in Giverny, 1887.
Essay by Spanierman Gallery, LLC
http://www.spanierman.com/feature/wu_bruce_blair.htm


Photos

1, 9, 10, 11, 21 : Les partenaires de l'Office de Tourisme: Vernon et environs
2 :Florence Griswold Museum http://www.flogris.org
4, 6, 7,8, 12,12,13,15, 16, 1
7, 20: Private collection
3: Tate gallery, Londres www.ibiblio.org/wm/ paint/auth/sargent/monet-wood/.
5 Spanierman gallery LLC - http://www.spanierman.com/index.html
14: Musée AG Poulain à Vernon, http:/www.ville-vernon27.fr/musee/
18, 20: Terra Foundation, www.terraamericanart.org
19: Unknown origin

More pages about Claude Monet and Giverny:
* Welcome to Giverny ( practical guide for visits)
* The making of Monet's garden
*
Giverny, where crossbreeding takes place
* List of plants and flowers in the garden
* Calendar of flowering times

*Giverny in Uncle Sam's country : Old Lyme and Cos Cob
* Giverny in the land of the Rising Sun : Kitagawa

and, to end the day in Giverny, a nice walk in the hills above Giverny